You know that moment when you're standing in front of the holiday dessert table, plate in hand, trying to decide between your grandmother's traditional fruitcake and that wild new peppermint cheesecake someone brought? Yeah, we've all been there. What if I told you that your Christmas food choices are more than just a simple decision—they're a direct line to Santa's infamous Naughty or Nice List?
Christmas foods aren't just about satisfying hunger—they're about tradition, memory, and those delightful moments that make the holiday season magical. Every bite tells a story, and sometimes, that story reveals more about your personality than you might expect.
Think about it:
- Your aunt's meticulously decorated sugar cookies
- Uncle Frank's experimental eggnog recipe
- Grandma's secret recipe passed down through generations
- Those store-bought treats you secretly love
Each of these foods carries a narrative, a piece of cultural identity that goes far beyond mere taste.
Christmas Foods Are More Than Just Calories
Researchers have long understood that food choices reflect more than just our taste preferences. They're windows into our personalities, our backgrounds, and our approach to life. And during Christmas? Those windows become panoramic views of our inner holiday spirit.
Fun Fact: Psychologists suggest that our food selections during holidays can reveal:
- Our comfort levels with tradition
- Our willingness to take culinary risks
- Our emotional connections to family and memories
- Our sense of adventure (or lack thereof)
What This Christmas Food Quiz Reveals About You
This isn't just another mindless internet quiz. This is a culinary personality decoder that will unlock the mysteries of your holiday food persona. Are you a traditionalist who respects every century-old recipe? Or are you the rebel who thinks fruitcake should be banned forever?
Our quiz will:
- Analyze your Christmas food preferences
- Match your choices to your personality type
- Determine whether you're destined for Santa's Naughty or Nice List
- Provide fun insights into your holiday spirit
How to Take the Christmas Food Quiz
- Clear your mind of any pre-existing holiday food judgments
- Answer each question honestly—no food-related guilt allowed
- Select the Christmas food that most speaks to your soul
- Avoid overthinking. Go with your first instinct
- Complete the quiz and receive your Naughty or Nice designation
Pro Tip: The more authentic you are, the more accurate your results will be. Santa's watching (but in a fun, non-creepy way).
Are you on Santa's naughty or nice list?
Are you ready to uncover the holiday truth hidden in your favorite Christmas treats? Santa's list awaits, and trust me, you want to know which side you're on.
Proceed with an empty stomach and an open mind.
Enjoy Quizly? Upgrade to Premium for an ad-free experience and exclusive features.
Get PremiumPlay More Quizzes
Christmas Food Quiz Questions
It's Christmas morning! What's for breakfast?
Santa pancakes
Christmas fruit tree
Christmas breakfast board
Breakfast casserole
Christmas porridge
None of these
Pick a drink.
Gingerbread latte
Eggnog
Candy cane milkshake
Chai
None of these
Hot cocoa
How about some cake too?
Gingerbread cake
Chocolate cake
Buccellato (Sicilian Christmas cake)
Candy cane cake
None of these
Fruitcake
And a cookie.
Grinch cookies
Peppermint cookies
Black and white cookies
None of these
Melomakarona (Greek Christmas honey cookie)
Linzer cookies
What's for lunch?
Duck breast, cream cheese, and cranberry sandwich
Truffle macaroni and cheese
Strawberry balsamic pasta salad
Vegan lasagna
None of these
Bolognese pasta
Pick a potato side.
Scalloped potatoes
Mashed potatoes
Roasted potatoes
Potato salad
Au gratin potatoes
None of these
Pick a peppermint drink.
Peppermint mocha
Peppermint tea
Peppermint latte
Peppermint frappuccino
Peppermint hot chocolate
None of these
Choose an appetizer for dinner.
Cheese wreath
Stocking flatbread
Cucumber and cream cheese bites
None of these
Deviled eggs
Charcuterie
Another.
Candy cane caprese salad
Rudolph's sliders
None of these
Cranberry and brie bites
Baked brie wreath
Pesto pull-apart tree
Choose a drink.
Gingerbread cocktail
Christmas punch
Hot toddy
None of these
Hot buttered rum
Mulled wine
What's next?
Green bean casserole
Tamales
Pigs in a blanket
Cornbread
Cheese platter
None of these
How about something meaty?
Pork roast
Sliced ham
None of these
Cornish hen
Vegan Wellington
Steak
Pick a veggie side.
Candied yams
Brussels sprouts
None of these
Slow-cooked parsnips
Green beans
Creamed spinach
Add another side.
Stuffing
Cranberry sauce
None of these
Gravy
Applesauce
Bread rolls
Choose a dessert.
Figgy pudding
Pavlova
Panettone
Fruit salad
None of these
Christmas trifle
One final treat to wrap it up:
None of these
Christmas brownies
Christmas tree cupcakes
Peanut butter fudge
Candy canes
Chocolate truffles
59 Comments
Naughty List!
bru, what did i do ;(
This is a great quiz ! Just one thing – Pigs in Blankets are mini sausages wrapped in Bacon, not pastry. (I’m British, so i know what they are)
Bruh I am on the naughty list
I got I’m on the Naughty List!
Wanna make an online friend. I’m a big fan of studio ghibli
BTW I got nice list slayyy
sure I need a friend also I got the nice list too
I got Naughty List
The world is your playground, and rules are more like gentle suggestions. You’ve got that magnetic energy that draws people in—unpredictable, clever, and always keeping everyone on their toes. Your spontaneity is your superpower, turning ordinary moments into unforgettable memories with just a mischievous grin. Santa’s watchlist just got a lot more interesting
MERRY CHRISTMAS! AND TO ALL A GOOD NIGHT!
HAPPY HOLIDAYS!
SEASON’S GREETINGS!
HAVE A HAPPY NEW YEAR!
Well, well, well… looks like someone’s got a wild side that comes out during the holidays! Forget following the crowd—you’re busy creating your own path. Witty, independent, and delightfully unexpected, you turn heads without even trying. Your confidence isn’t about breaking rules, but about knowing exactly who you are. Life is your stage, and you’re the star of your own epic performance.
Bro im not naughty but thats what we all think
You got: Naughty List!
The world is your playground, and rules are more like gentle suggestions. You’ve got that magnetic energy that draws people in—unpredictable, clever, and always keeping everyone on their toes. Your spontaneity is your superpower, turning ordinary moments into unforgettable memories with just a mischievous grin. Santa’s watchlist just got a lot more interesting!
hey I am trying to make a online friend
btw I love Harry potter
Hi! I just made my first online friend yesterday! I LOVE HARRY POTTER and that is how we became friends! As long as you don’t say anything inappropriate we are cool!
nice
I’m on santa’s nice list🧑🎄
nice list I’m surprised tho
I am a little surprised I got nice because I really haven’t been to good this year!
same
slay Maya slayyyyyy
Naughty list – no surprise there: Oh, you food maverick! Your Christmas food choices scream ‘I do what I want!’ Spontaneous and bold, you’re not afraid to challenge the status quo. Your inner rebel comes with a side of charm that makes people both laugh and slightly nervous. Life’s too short for playing it safe, and you’ve got the spark to prove it.
That is what I got too!!
Naughty list
I figured- i’m not always a good kid
Same
Naughty List
The world is your playground, and rules are more like gentle suggestions. You’ve got that magnetic energy that draws people in—unpredictable, clever, and always keeping everyone on their toes. Your spontaneity is your superpower, turning ordinary moments into unforgettable memories with just a mischievous grin. Santa’s watchlist just got a lot more interesting!
same
Naughty List.
Oh, naughty list for me! How peachy.
Quite frankly, I highly doubt that my food choices are a reflection of my behavior. This quiz is implying that eating one thing as opposed to another has a direct correlation to my actions and choices. Does anybody else here find this to be a trifle absurd? 🤣
All in all, as this was in fact a pleasurable quiz, I am dubious of its accuracy.
I’m on the naughty list
On the nice list.
You’re on Santa’s Nice List!
Your food choices are a testament to kindness, tradition, and pure holiday magic. You’re the person who makes everyone feel welcome, turns meals into memories, and keeps the true meaning of the season alive. Your emotional intelligence is your superpower, allowing you to navigate relationships with grace and genuine care. You don’t just belong in rooms—you elevate them. Santa’s definitely got you on speed dial.
Santa’s Nice List! 😆
Naughty list
Goody. I’m on the naughty list.
I got naughty list
The Nice List. I’ll go with that, especially the authentic and grounded part.
I got Naughty 🤣
The world is your playground, and rules are more like gentle suggestions. You’ve got that magnetic energy that draws people in—unpredictable, clever, and always keeping everyone on their toes. Your spontaneity is your superpower, turning ordinary moments into unforgettable memories with just a mischievous grin. Santa’s watchlist just got a lot more interesting!
I knew I was on the naughty list :O
I’m not a good teenager. LOL
At least you’re independent minded and strong willed 🤘
yay
Got the same thing
I do not know how they got it so right
LOL me neither. it never gets me right
Relatable!!
Nice List!
Congratulations! You’re the human embodiment of holiday cheer, with taste buds that scream ‘wholesome Christmas spirit’. Deeply empathetic and kind, you have a magical ability to make everyone around you feel seen and appreciated. Your genuine heart creates connections that last a lifetime. People gravitate towards you like a cozy fireplace on a cold winter night.
Hi it’s me, vienna! I just changed my profile to Luna Lovegood.
I thought I would be on the naughty list, but I’m on the nice list!
I LOVE YOUR PROFILE PICTURE! Hogwarts is like my dream school!
Yess, me too!
Yes! I’m turning 11 next year so hopefully I get to go to Hogwarts! I knew your comment would be about Harry Potter because of your username! And you use Wizarding World, I assume?
Nice! I’m 12, but I didn’t make it to Hogwarts unfortunately. What do you mean by using Wizarding World?
Like, you have an account on it and you got sorted into your house, and you got your wand, and you produced your Patronus, things like that.
Ohhh. Yes I have an account. My house is Slytherin, as you know. My wand is Yew wood with a unicorn core 11 ½” and unbending flexibility. And my Patronus is a Hippogriff! Do you have an account. (Just know, I hate to be bothering you, especially since we probably have time differences.)
Ok, I’ll see you tomorrow maybe! Byee 😀
Me too! This is my first online friend I’ve ever made and i’m super excited right now! BTW my bedtime is at 7:45 and right now for me it’s 7:20, so I can’t be here for much longer.
Yay! I knew you would say yes! I knew because we’ve been talking to each other for a day already and we’re really nice and cool to each other! And we both have a love for Harry Potter! I’m glad we’re friends!
YES, Vienna! I would love to be friends! (I replied in two places, but I can’t reply to you here, and I don’t think the other reply came through.)
No, it’s okay, it’s around 4:00 pm where I’m at right now. I also have an account, my house is Slytherin, my want wood is English Oak Wood, phoenix feather core, 12 1/2″ and surprisingly swishy flexibility.
Hey, do you want to be friends?
I noticed you’d changed your profile. Fan of Harry Potter?
Good for you btw
nice
Congratulations! You’re the human embodiment of holiday cheer, with taste buds that scream ‘wholesome Christmas spirit’. Deeply empathetic and kind, you have a magical ability to make everyone around you feel seen and appreciated. Your genuine heart creates connections that last a lifetime. People gravitate towards you like a cozy fireplace on a cold winter night.
You’re on the Nice List
Santa’s got a special spot reserved just for you! Your holiday food preferences are like a warm hug for the soul—comforting, genuine, and filled with love. You’re the friend everyone can count on, the person who shows up with a plan and a smile. Your thoughtfulness isn’t just a trait—it’s an art form. You create safety and joy wherever you go, making the world a little brighter with your consistent kindness.
girlllll everything is good 4 u