Here's the first one: Which old-school dessert do you like more?

Bread and butter pudding
Sticky toffee pudding
Both
Neither

Which dessert will you pick?

Brown Betty
Watergate cake
Both
Neither

Would you rather have strawberry pretzel salad or blancmange?

Strawberry pretzel salad
Blancmange
Both
Neither

Which one would it be?

Charlotte Russe
Trifle
Both
Neither

Which old-timey dessert do you find more appealing: vanilla rice pudding or crown jewel dessert?

Vanilla rice pudding
Crown jewel dessert (broken window glass dessert)
Both
Neither

Which throwback dessert is your fave?

Chocolate wacky cake
Bananas Foster
Both
Neither

Which old-fashioned dessert do you prefer?

Fruit cocktail pudding
Pink bavarian cream
Both
Neither

Which retro dessert would you choose?

Apple crisp
Tunnel of fudge cake
Both
Neither

Which dessert is more appealing to you?

Chess pie
Fruitcake
Both
Neither

Which classic dessert will you choose: pineapple upside-down cake or Lady Baltimore cake?

Pineapple upside-down cake
Lady Baltimore cake
Both
Neither

You're at the halfway point! Which dessert strikes your fancy: 7-Up pound cake or Boston cream pie?

7-Up pound cake
Boston cream pie
Both
Neither

Which retro dessert sounds better to you?

Lime walnut cake
Jell-O pudding brownies
Both
Neither

Which throwback dessert is calling out to you: lemon chiffon cake or cherries jubilee?

Lemon chiffon cake
Cherries Jubilee
Both
Neither

Which classic dessert can you go for right now: crepes suzette or fruit cobbler?

Crepes suzette
Fruit cobbler
Both
Neither

Which dessert would you go for: peach melba or malt milkshake?

Peach melba
Malt milkshake
Both
Neither

Which vintage dessert strikes your fancy: Watergate salad or poke cake?

Watergate salad
Poke cake
Both
Neither

What is your choice of dessert?

Jelly and ice cream
Sugar cream pie
Both
Neither

Almost there! Which retro dessert is calling your name?

Coca-Cola Jell-O salad
Coca-Cola cake
Both
Neither

Which old-school dessert would it be?

Junket
Blondie
Both
Neither

And finally, which dessert are you more keen on: Black Forest cake or snickerdoodle?

Black Forest cake
Snickerdoodle
Both
Neither

Share the quiz to show your results!

I Know What Holiday Matches Your Energy Purely by the Throwback Desserts You’d Rather Eat

%%personality%%

Share Result in Comment

New

Replay

💡 Did you know? You can resume your quizzes at any point — even if you close your browser. Never lose track of your progress again!

Prev Quiz Next Quiz

Add a Comment Cancel reply

5 Comments

⚠️ May contain spoilers

Join the Conversation

Fetching Conversations

Top Commenters

Most comments in last 30 days

Counting Comments

Unlock Premium Perks

Enjoy Quizly? Upgrade to Premium for an ad-free experience and exclusive features.

Get Premium

Top Quizzes in Retro Food

Explore All

Top Quizzes in Holidays

Explore All

Top Quizzes in Would You Rather?

Explore All

Play More Quizzes

🆕 Latest 🎲 Random 👤 Personality 🍔 Food 🧠 General Knowledge ❤️ Love Who Am I?🧩 Themed Trivia 🪄 Harry Potter ☕ Lifestyle 🏰 Disney 🌎 Geography 🔮 Read My Fortune 👗 Fashion & Style 🤔 Can We Guess?💡 Self-Discovery 🧘 Health & Wellness 🍿 Movies 📺 Television 💥 Marvel 🐶 Pets & Animals 🌴 Travel 🎭 Arts & Literature 💬 Language 📸 Celebs 🌈 All About Colors 🪩 Retro & Nostalgia

Fetching plays

Your Support Makes a Difference

Here's the first one: Which old-school dessert do you like more?

Which dessert will you pick?

Would you rather have strawberry pretzel salad or blancmange?

Which one would it be?

Which old-timey dessert do you find more appealing: vanilla rice pudding or crown jewel dessert?

Which throwback dessert is your fave?

Which old-fashioned dessert do you prefer?

Which retro dessert would you choose?

Which dessert is more appealing to you?

Which classic dessert will you choose: pineapple upside-down cake or Lady Baltimore cake?

You're at the halfway point! Which dessert strikes your fancy: 7-Up pound cake or Boston cream pie?

Which retro dessert sounds better to you?

Which throwback dessert is calling out to you: lemon chiffon cake or cherries jubilee?

Which classic dessert can you go for right now: crepes suzette or fruit cobbler?

Which dessert would you go for: peach melba or malt milkshake?

Which vintage dessert strikes your fancy: Watergate salad or poke cake?

What is your choice of dessert?

Almost there! Which retro dessert is calling your name?

Which old-school dessert would it be?

And finally, which dessert are you more keen on: Black Forest cake or snickerdoodle?

Free Quiz of the Day

%%personality%%

Copy Result Link

Try These Quizzes Next

Add a Comment Cancel reply

5 Comments

Top Commenters

Top Quizzes in Retro Food

Top Quizzes in Holidays

Top Quizzes in Would You Rather?

Play More Quizzes

Unlock Premium Features

New Report

Close